The hidden costs of “All-In-One” platforms

5 min read
May 28, 2024

Enterprise e-commerce businesses are constantly seeking the most efficient and cost-effective ways to establish and grow their online presence. The promise of “all-in-one” platforms seems alluring: a single solution that covers every aspect of the e-commerce funnel. To certain brands, this premise makes perfect sense: Keep every piece together and make the most of software that allows for quick startup speeds, convenient app installs, and the opportunity to grow to become a viable business.

However, for enterprise brands, this convenience comes with hidden costs that can impact your business's flexibility, performance, and bottom line. By exploring these hidden costs, we aim to shed light on why a best-of-breed approach, especially one that leverages a headless architecture, might be a more strategic choice for your e-commerce business.

The Illusion of Convenience

Monolithic Platforms: A Single Point of Control

Monolithic platforms such as Shopify and Salesforce Commerce Cloud offer a comprehensive package that includes everything from website building tools, hosting, payment gateways, inventory management, and analytics. This bundled offering promises ease of use and streamlined operations, presenting a tempting proposition for businesses looking to simplify their tech stack.

However, the reality is that by committing to a monolithic platform, businesses often find themselves constrained by the limitations inherent in these all-in-one solutions. While these platforms offer many tools, none are necessarily the best the market has to offer. This can result in missed sales targets, unrealized cart potential, and diluted brand identity.

The Hidden Financial Costs

Transaction Fees and Payment Structures

One of the most significant hidden costs of using an all-in-one platform is the payment structure. Platforms like Shopify charge transaction fees on top of regular subscription fees unless you use their proprietary payment gateway, Shopify Payments. This creates a double whammy: businesses pay for the convenience of an integrated system and incur additional costs for each transaction processed through third-party payment providers.

For instance, Shopify charges up to 2% per transaction if you use external payment gateways, which can significantly eat into your margins, especially for high-volume sellers. This fee structure can become a substantial financial burden, reducing profitability over time.

Subscription and Platform Fees

Beyond transaction fees, the base subscription costs of monolithic platforms can be quite steep. While the initial setup might seem affordable, the cumulative expenses of maintaining a subscription, coupled with costs for premium features or add-ons, can quickly add up. For example, Salesforce Commerce Cloud's tiered pricing model can escalate with the growth of your business, as fees are often based on the volume of sales and number of users.

Maintenance and Customization Constraints

The convenience of an all-in-one platform often comes at the expense of flexibility. Customization options are typically limited to what the platform allows, and significant changes can be difficult or impossible to implement. This lack of flexibility can stifle innovation and prevent businesses from tailoring their e-commerce experience to meet unique customer needs or market demands.

Moreover, when issues arise, you're often dependent on the platform's support team. While this centralized support can be helpful, it also means you're at the mercy of their response times and resolution capabilities. If a critical issue affects your site during peak sales periods, the delays in support can lead to lost revenue and frustrated customers.

The Best-of-Breed Approach: Flexibility and Optimization

Customization and Performance

A headless e-commerce approach separates the front-end presentation layer from the back-end functionality, allowing businesses to choose best-of-breed solutions for each component of their tech stack. This means you can select the most advanced and suitable tools for payments, CRM, analytics, and more, rather than being constrained by the one-size-fits-all offerings of a monolithic platform.

For example, using a specialized payment provider like Stripe Link can offer lower transaction fees and more advanced fraud protection than what’s available through an all-in-one platform. Nacelle’s partnership with Stripe empowers your brand to customize the checkout and put it anywhere on the site with no requirement to redirect out of the experience.

Improved Site Speed and Conversion Rates

Headless commerce enables businesses to optimize every aspect of their site’s performance, from loading speeds to checkout processes. Businesses can optimize their site's performance to load quickly and efficiently, thereby reducing bounce rates and enhancing the overall user experience. This level of performance tuning is often not possible with monolithic platforms, which are designed to work adequately for a broad range of users rather than being optimized for peak performance.

Ownership and Brand Identity

One of the most significant advantages of a best-of-breed approach is the ability to fully own and control your e-commerce experience. By building a custom front end and integrating it with the best back-end services, you create a unique digital experience that aligns with your brand identity. This level of ownership extends to the checkout process, where you can design a seamless and intuitive user journey that enhances customer satisfaction and boosts conversion rates.

Cost Efficiency and Scalability

While a headless approach might seem more complex and potentially more expensive upfront, it often proves more cost-effective in the long run. By avoiding the recurring fees and transaction costs associated with monolithic platforms, businesses can reinvest those savings into other areas, such as marketing, product development, or customer service.

Moreover, a headless architecture is inherently more scalable. As your business grows, you can easily integrate new services or upgrade existing ones without being tied to the limitations of an all-in-one platform. This flexibility ensures that your e-commerce stack can evolve with your business needs, providing a future-proof solution.

Real World Example: ILIA Beauty

ILIA Beauty, a direct-to-consumer brand, initially chose Shopify for its ease of setup and comprehensive features. Recognizing the need to remain competitive, they moved from a performant Shopify Plus storefront to a headless architecture and a composable, modern tech stack leveraging Nacelle. This strategic shift aimed to enhance both the customer experience and developer workflow.

ILIA Beauty shared Nacelle's vision of empowering engineering teams to create unique, differentiating systems and experiences. By leveraging modern technologies and frameworks, ILIA sought to personalize the online beauty buying experience for their customers.

ILIA launched their first headless site, resulting in significant performance improvements: a 48% decrease in page load time on mobile and a 46% decrease on desktop. This transition allowed ILIA's engineering team to focus on innovative problem-solving and creating new customer connections instead of grappling with platform limitations.

New custom experiences, such as the "Find My Shade" quiz and product recommendation engine, illustrate the enhanced capabilities of their headless setup. ILIA is a perfect example of how a modern platform and flexible content modeling can reduce daily workflow friction and enable the creation of new, higher converting customer experiences.

What will you choose?

While all-in-one platforms like Shopify and Salesforce Commerce Cloud offer the allure of convenience, they come with hidden costs that can limit your business’s growth and profitability. By ceding control to these monolithic solutions, you may find yourself shackled by high transaction fees, limited customization options, and suboptimal performance.

In contrast, a best-of-breed approach, particularly one that embraces headless commerce, provides the flexibility, performance, and cost efficiency needed to thrive in today’s competitive e-commerce landscape. By carefully selecting and integrating the best tools for each aspect of your e-commerce stack, you can create a powerful, scalable, and unique online presence that drives growth and success.

Don’t let the hidden costs of convenience hold you back. Embrace the future of e-commerce with a headless, best-of-breed approach and unlock the full potential of your business.

Receive our latest blogs directly into your inbox